You will be happy to know that obscenity charges against this singer have been dropped by the Malaysian moral police. You couldn't really fault Malaysian authorities when in our own backyard artists like Khushboo are continuously hounded.Yet, there is a sign that conservatism is on the rise in Malaysia.
In August, pop star Gwen Stefani was told to dress "modestly" for a concert after the National Union of Malaysia Muslim Students protested on the grounds that she would bring an "American hegemonic background," said the group's president, Hilmi Ramli. Last month, singer Beyonce Knowles canceled her Nov. 1 debut concert in Malaysia. [..]Student groups are very active supporters of these measures. As Rushdie said in his book Midnight's Children, it is funny that in these cultures students actually clamor for more control!
Authorities have required Malaysian rock stars to cut their hair or forfeit the opportunity to appear on TV or radio, and frequently remind Malaysians of the consequences for openly addressing "sensitive" issues such as race and religion. In 2005, the standards were extended to foreign performers, who were required to be covered from shoulder to knees and prohibited from hugging or kissing fellow artists or audience members, jumping or shouting, cursing, or exchanging objects with the audience.
"They have to dress decently ... and behave in a manner appropriate in Malaysia," said Arts, Culture and Heritage Minister Rais Yatim. [link]
Of course, none of this really concerns us and according to some, shouldn't concern us. Alas, if only everyone accepted this dictum of national boundaries and statehood vs. identity. We have a situation where if a butterfly flutters its wings anywhere, we get into trouble. There is a pattern and predictability to these things, for instance, all the bloggers protesting against the crackdown on ethnic Hindus are actually ethnic Chinese.
Yeah, okay, calling the economic and social hardships of Malaysian Indian society an "ethnic cleansing" isn't exactly the smartest thing in the world you could do, because 1) no one will take you seriously, and 2) it only offers the Government free ammunition. (Re: Tian Chua.) Also, the people of Darfur would like to have a word with you. It was an outrageous statement, and the Hindraf leaders can't possibly be stupid enough to believe it.Before coming to the ethnic cleansing claims, one more from the same blogger:
But at the same time... it worked, didn't it? Hindraf's been around since, what, May? Now, I haven't been in Malaysia since February, but I seriously doubt most people even heard of Hindraf. (I did, but never heard from them again.) They were about as effective as, well, a Malaysian opposition, really. [link]
Everyone's dodging the real issue, of course: that Indians have been fucked around more than any other race in Malaysian history. Don't give me that nonsense about how other races have it bad too - no one has it as bad as the Malaysian Indians. It's not even up for debate. The Malays have the bumi thing going for them. The Chinese have the business world practically locked up. (Yes, I'm generalising here. Doesn't make it less true.) What do the Indians have? They don't even have opportunities. (Again, generalising, but you get the idea by now.) So let's not pretend that "we're all suffering equally". [emphasis in original]However, none of this is surprising or new. It is hardly surprising that only the ethnic Chinese will support the Hindus in Malaysia, just as it isn't surprising that the Chinese will not have too much problems in Malaysia. First of all, ethnic Chinese people control all the powerful and economically advanced states in the region - China, Hong Kong, Taiwan. If Malays mess with Chinese they will get their ass kicked all over South China Sea. What is important is how strongly the Malaysian Government reacted to the allegations of ethnic cleansing:
In a statement reflective of the growing tension in Malaysia over ethnic clashes, the country’s Prime Minister Abdullah Badawi on Sunday offered to resign if the allegation of ethnic cleansing of Indian Tamils was proved. Outraged at the allegations levelled against his government by a local Hindu group, Badawi said the statements were aimed at dividing Malaysia. "I rarely get angry but this time I am very angry and this is something I cannot accept," Abdullah was quoted as saying by the New Straits Times. [link]This is merely the PR front, action is being taken behind the scenes as well. The Government has ordered the detention of Hindraf leaders. Contrast this with the allegations of genocide in India and the reaction of our people friendly Government.
Whether we can support Hindraf or not, we should be thankful to them for forcing an objective evaluation of terms such as genocide, pogrom etc., which are being thrown around too casually for far too long.



















